EU Council backs Poland to suspend asylum amid criticism from advocacy groups
October 18, Pozirk. Russia, Belarus or any other country cannot be allowed to abuse Europe’s values, including the right to asylum, and to undermine its democracies, the European Council said today at the Brussels summit.
The statement by the European Union institution that defines the EU’s general political direction and priorities comes as Polish Prime Minister Donald Tusk faces severe criticism from advocacy groups and politicians for his migration strategy, which provides for the “territorial” suspension of the right to asylum.
The move may expose to risks thousands of Belarusians seeking asylum in Poland after fleeing politically-motivated persecution in Belarus.
The EU Council, however, sided with the Polish prime minister.
“Exceptional situations require appropriate measures. The European Council recalls its determination to ensure effective control of the Union’s external borders through all available means, including with the support of the European Union, in line with EU and international law. It reaffirms its commitment to countering the instrumentalisation of migrants for political purposes,” it said.
The suspension of asylum procedures has come under fire from Amnesty International. The plan is brazenly illegal, said Dinushika Dissanayake, its deputy regional director for Europe.
“EU member states like Poland are playing politics with the rights of refugees and migrants,” she said in a statement on October 16. “From Poland to Finland, Greece and Germany, so-called emergencies are being weaponized to enact laws that gravely undermine access to asylum and the protection from refoulement.”
Proposals to temporarily suspend asylum rights put the rights of people seeking safety at risk, the human rights activist noted. They punish people who may have been subject to violence and human trafficking, or “lured to EU borders under false pretenses.”
Dissanayake also said these proposals were clearly at odds with the EU’s recently adopted crisis regulation under the Pact on Migration and Asylum.
“States have a range of tools available to respond to security concerns, which must in all cases uphold human rights, including the right to asylum, as protected by the EU Charter on Fundamental Rights,” she stressed. “Since 2021, the EU has been tolerating practices enacted by Poland, Latvia and Lithuania at their borders with Belarus that go beyond all powers granted to them under EU law, and more recently at Finland’s border with Russia. It is high time for the European Commission to take its role as guardian of the treaties seriously and send a clear message that fundamental rights cannot be bent to political interests.”
The EU summit is taking place on October 17–18 with migration high on the agenda. European leaders discuss, among other things, strengthening control over the EU’s frontier and combating human trafficking and smuggling.
Duda criticizes new migration strategy as a mistake
- PoliticsInterior ministry brands 21 people as extremistsThe material is available only to POZIRK+
- PoliticsOpposition politician promotes creative activismThe material is available only to POZIRK+
- SocietyOfficials expect birth rates to start growing by 2030The material is available only to POZIRK+
- EconomyBelarusian engineers develop motor for EVThe material is available only to POZIRK+
- PoliticsUS diplomat discusses political prisoners at Belarus' foreign ministryThe material is available only to POZIRK+
- PoliticsAuthorities seize former BelaPAN journalist’s propertyThe material is available only to POZIRK+
- Security
- PoliticsCommission for political returnees to examine queries from people inside BelarusThe material is available only to POZIRK+
- Economy
- PoliticsBelarus blocks access to online bookstoreThe material is available only to POZIRK+
- Security
- SecurityUkrainian Air Force reports new Russian drone incursions into BelarusThe material is available only to POZIRK+
- Politics
- PoliticsReprisals: foreigners arrestedThe material is available only to POZIRK+
- EconomyWorld Bank revises upward Belarus' growth forecastThe material is available only to POZIRK+
- Politics
- PoliticsAnother dead Nazi criminal to be tried in BelarusThe material is available only to POZIRK+
- EconomyBelarus’ economic growth unsustainable – think tankThe material is available only to POZIRK+
- PoliticsRights groups label four as political prisonersThe material is available only to POZIRK+
- PoliticsOpposition discusses sanctions against Minsk with Canadian MPsThe material is available only to POZIRK+
- PoliticsMoscow court postpones trial of pundit Suzdaltsev accused of criticizing ŁukašenkaThe material is available only to POZIRK+
- PoliticsPoland to set up special border guard unitThe material is available only to POZIRK+
- Security
- SocietyRoman Catholic priest leaves Belarus after jail sentenceThe material is available only to POZIRK+
- SecurityBelarus' interior minister seeks to boost police cooperation with TurkeyThe material is available only to POZIRK+
- Economy
- Economy
- PoliticsAt least 170 sentenced for political reasons in September – ViasnaThe material is available only to POZIRK+
- SecurityLatvia reports annual record of illegal entries from BelarusThe material is available only to POZIRK+
- SecurityDrone incursions reported overnightThe material is available only to POZIRK+